(AUG 24) Watching a tape of the
recent Strike Force MMA bout between Gina Carano and Cristiane
Santos (nee Cyborg), I was reminded of a soccer game. I don't really
understand soccer, either. I'm sure soccer players and female MMA
fighters are gifted athletes and their sports require a good deal of
skill, but when announcers talk of "game plans" and "strategy," I'm
at a loss, particularly with MMA; it only recalls, for me, long ago,
4 AM "last calls" and parking lots behind gin mills. But just as I
know there is much more to soccer than ninety minutes of running,
kicking and very little scoring, I also know there has to be more to
MMA than kicking, gouging, hitting your opponent when their back is
turned or when they're flat on the ring surface. I just don't get it
and that's, probably, on me.
What I did get as I watched the Carano/Santos tape is why the MMA,
as a sport, is making progress, from the near obscurity and disdain
the sport engendered only a few years ago: MMA has leadership, it
has disciplined leadership whose goal is to continue to build the
sport through a clearly defined communication plan. Go back and
watch the Carano/Santos tape and notice how often the fighters, the
trainers, even the announcers talk, generically, about the sport,
about the athleticism of the athletes, the training discipline they
endure and, in general, sell the sport of mixed martial arts. This
is not done haphazardly, it is done with the discipline and
direction often associated with a well oiled political machine. And
that leadership and that communication plan has been effective in
propelling MMA to it's current, improved position on the food chain
of ring sports. It is exactly what the sport of Women's boxing
needs, and at present does not have: a communication process that
extols the sport and it's athletes. At present, there exists only
sporadic news of the sport which consists, largely, of material
about individual fighters or bouts. While that is fine in a news
gathering sense, it conveys little about a sport that has not only
survived, viably, for over two decades but has increased the number
of talented boxers in it's ranks by quantum leaps. But the fact is
that if Women's boxing is to remain a productive sport, in the face
of competition such as MMA, the sport has to do a much better job of
selling itself, not only individual boxers, not only the rare, high
profile bout, but the sport itself and the skill level within that
sport that those two decades ago, would have been dismissed as
wishful thinking. That's the message that Women's boxing must get
across to the mainstream sports fan and, at this point in time,
Women's boxing lacks a primary ingredient for accomplishing that
task: leadership. Women's boxing has none.
Make no mistake, the top level athletes who populate the sport of
Women's boxing are every bit as talented in their sport as Gina
Carano and Cris Santos, probably more so. However, the sport of
Women's boxing lags far behind when it comes to generic support,
from within the sport. There is a distinct lack of communication
about the skill, ability, training, discipline and dedication it
takes to compete at the highest level of female boxing. Listen to
Women's boxing interviews, read the pr releases, endure the innane
"call outs," each seems to concentrate on the self interested agenda
of a manager, trainer, sanctioning body or boxer who is doing the
talking or issuing the press release. While there is certainly a
surfeit of that kind of publicity in the MMA, it is, almost always,
accompanied by at least a fair share of words and pictures talking
up the virtues of the mixed martial arts sport, generically selling
the sport at every possible opportunity. Women's boxing has to begin
doing more of that type of promoting. The sport is stocked with
talented professional female boxers as never before in history. And
yet, a "civilian" asked me the other day, "when is Laila Ali's next
fight." Laila Ali is gone and she's probably not coming back. The
other "well known face" of the sport, Christy Martin, is on her
"farewell tour," seeking a fifty win plateau. The names of Ali and
Martin and their careers in Women's boxing continue to be
recognized, rightfully so, but, in reality, the sport cannot count
on nostalgia to sell female boxing in the face of, present day,
increased competition from the likes of MMA. The fact is, by
comparison, the sport of Women's boxing has more skilled boxers and
talent, than existed during the best days of Ali and certainly the
early days of Martin. But that fact has not reached the sports fan,
it has not even reached some boxing fans. The sport of Women's
boxing, throughout it's modern existence, has never, effectively,
sold the sport as a compelling competition between two highly
skilled athletes. MMA is doing exactly that now and, as a result,
continues to pose an increasingly larger threat to Women's boxing, a
sport I feel is far superior.
Can Women's boxing be successfully sold on a generic basis? One
answer, of course, is the 2012 Olympics. Dr. Chiang-Kuo Wu sold the
previously ignored sport of amateur female boxing to the Olympic
committee based on the increasing level of skill in the sport and
the burgeoning number of talented amateur female fighters around the
globe. This was, virtually, an unknown element, certainly to those
who were making Olympic inclusion decisions until the selling job
Dr. Wu and his team accomplished, based solely on the appeal of the
sport. There were no "famous" names for Dr. Wu to talk about only
the skill of the amateur fighters around the world and the
compatibility of those fighters and their sport to the Olympics . In
this country, Bonnie Canino, whose name belongs in the lead graph of
any story of US amateur female boxing, continues to grow her gold
standard program in Florida without the aid of big name boxers.
Canino, rather, sells the sport and the athletes based on the skill
displayed in the ring and the excitement that skill engenders. It's
exactly the type of selling job the sport of Women's boxing, on a
professional level, needs to initiate. The sport and it's athletes
need to be sold as an attraction, not just separately as boxers, or
personalities but as a sport that combines all the elements that
appeal to an ever younger, ever growing base of sports fan. Then and
only then can the sport hope to regain the type of niche in the
television landscape that it once enjoyed, a niche currently
occupied by MMA.
Who's going to sell Women's boxing? It would be comfortable to
envision a utopian concept, whereby a consortium of managers, former
fighters, trainers, commission officials, sanctioning body personnel
and others in the female "boxing community" come together to jointly
conceptualize and lead such an effort. In reality, putting together
such a diverse group of strong willed personalities such as these,
all with different agendas and ideas as to what the future of the
sport of Women's boxing needs to be successful is probably fanciful,
at best. It seems obvious, to me, if any group is in a position to
sell the sport of Women's boxing, it is the sport's sanctioning
bodies. They are, by their nature, in competition with each other,
they have varying levels of personnel and resources, but they have
one thing in common, their future success depends on the success of
the sport of Women's boxing. If, as is entirely possible, these
groups cannot come together in any kind of joint effort, the
alternative would be for each Women's boxing sanctioning body, at
the very least, to allocate some time, effort and, yes, resources to
selling the sport, along with their individual bouts, championship
belts and programs. The MMA, as a sport, is doing it and doing it
well. Women's boxing has to begin to match that competition, selling
point for selling point.
Nearly fifty years ago, a good man implored his fellow citizens to
"ask not" what their country could do for them, and urged them,
instead, to look beyond individual agendas and contribute to the
betterment of the whole. A paraphrase of his words might have
application, today, to everyone with a vested interest in the future
betterment of the sport of Women's boxing, "....ask what you can do
for the sport."
Bernie McCoy