The sport of Women's boxing surely has
enough problems to overcome: good fighters adamantly refusing to
climb in the ring with other top fighters, promoters determined to
protect their boxers inside a hometown cocoon, largely irrelevant
sanctioning bodies that, in reality, would have trouble sanctioning
a one car parade, and a media, largely ignorant of all but the most
superficial aspects of the sport, wasting television coverage on
"walkover" showcase bouts featuring "name" fighters, leaving more
compelling, competitive fights un-televised.
Unfortunately, the sport must now endure an outbreak of stupidity
that has reared up once again: fighters publicly challenging other
fighters with what are euphemistically termed "callouts." While
these public challenges are certainly not as detrimental to the
sport as the other major problems mentioned, these "callouts" manage
to achieve an infamous distinction all their own.....they are
inanely foolish, or, better, in the words of Macbeth "....a tale
Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing."
The "callout," which has been around since almost the beginning of
the sport, is discomfiting for any number of reasons but none more
obvious than the simple fact that throughout the history Women's
boxing, never, not once, have "callouts" ever resulted in a bout
that a fan would go across a street, a very narrow street, to watch.
"Callouts" didn't help
Lucia Rijker get
in the ring with Christy Martin, "callouts" didn't help
Sumya Anani match-up
with Rijker or any of the other fighters Anani was forced to pursue
over the last three years, and certainly no credible super
middleweight fighter has been able to lure the self proclaimed
"face" of the sport,
Laila Ali,
into the ring with any manner of public challenge.
That fact, alone, begs the question: why, if a tactic doesn't work,
is it continuously employed? In the case of "callouts," there may be
a couple of reasons: certainly frustration at the inability of good
fighters to get a bout with other good fighters plays a part. There
is also the age old tactic of acquiring publicity by "coat-tailing"
a fighter who is currently in the public spotlight.
Let's examine the frustration issue.
Jelena
Mrdjenovich
has never fought outside her home country of Canada, the vast
majority of her bouts occurring in Edmonton, Ontario. Her promoter,
with some validity, points out that Mrdjenovich makes more money
fighting before hometown fans. To date, however, this has somewhat
limited her opposition. Mrdjenovich has won all but one of her 16
bouts and is, by any definition, a good fighter.
However, her recent
successful defense of her WBC super featherweight title was
contested against
Donna
Biggers
whose 18-3-1 record can be termed, accurately, "a bit soft" (her
wins came against fighters who had a 15-31 cumulative record). Not
surprisingly, the fight was stopped after the second round. This win
precipitated a series of "callouts" from fighters who want a chance
at that WBC title and they want it in bouts outside of Canada.
These
challenges, not surprisingly, came from representatives of
Chevelle Hallback
and
Layla McCarter
(the fighter who handed Mrdjenovich her lone loss and who returned
to the ring last Saturday with a decision over Victoria Cisneros
after recovering from a serious arm injury sustained in a return
bout with Mrdjenovich ). However, it was the "callout" from the team
of
Jessica Rakoczy
that took the award for convoluted logic and should also serve as an
object lesson for the value of rereading something before it's made
public.
Jessica Rakoczy is, also, a good fighter, with only two losses on
her record against 22 wins. Rakoczy is promoted by Christian Printup
who has kept his fighter geographically encased, as far as her bouts
are concerned, within the state of California, in and around the
Fresno and Lemoore area, for the last three and one half years. To
his credit, Printup has matched Rakoczy against some very good
boxers,
Jane Couch,
Eliza Olson,
Belinda Laracuente,
Lisa Lewis
and
Jenifer
Alcorn and,
in the process, Printup has probably put together as many good
female boxing match-ups as any promoter in the country. It's obvious
Christian Printup knows a good bout when he sees one and Rakoczy/Mrdjenovich
is just that, a good bout. The problem ensued when Printup went into
"callout" mode. He started by making a valid call for Mrdjenovich's
handlers "to bring her down" from Canada to a "neutral site" in the
U S to fight Rakoczy. So far, so good. However, it's at this
juncture that Printup goes from "callout" mode to standup comedy.
With what I assume was a straight face, Christian Printup identifies
the "neutral" site for the Rakoczy/Mrdjenovich bout as Lemoore, CA.
The same Lemoore, CA, where Jessica Rakoczy has fought her last 13
bouts and has another scheduled for mid-April.
Printup's logic is
that Jessica Rakoczy was born in Canada (Hamilton, Ontario).
However, one might note that the next time Jessica Rakoczy steps
into a professional boxing ring in Canada, it will be the first
time. Lemoore CA is as much of a neutral site for Jessica Rakoczy as
Edmonton, Ontario is for Jelena Mrdjenovich. As stated, Jessica
Rakoczy and Jelena Mrdjenovich is a good fight, but "callouts" such
as this, which might more properly belong on "Saturday Night Live",
are not the way to make the bout.
Should Mrdjenovich venture from
Canada to fight? Sure! But if a neutral site is the goal, don't make
it the other fighter's "home court." How about a home/home, two bout
deal, one in Lemoore, the return in Edmonton since Rakoczy/Mrdjenovich
is a main event bout in any country. But, for everyone's sake, lets
lose the silly "callout."
Then there's Melissa Hernandez, a "seasoned veteran" of two
fights, who recently felt compelled up to "callout"
Maureen
Shea, who has had
five fights. Shea has benefited from considerable publicity, largely
attributable to her work on the movie, "Million Dollar Baby".
Hernandez, on the other hand, has not been the beneficiary of any
such press coverage. (In the interest of full disclosure, I should
stipulate that I recently did a story on Maureen Shea and I,
likewise, confess I have never written a line about Melissa
Hernandez, most probably a shortcoming on my part). Hernandez seems
to have, shrewdly, figured out that if you can't get publicity on
your own, challenge someone who is getting publicity. It's smart
marketing, the boxing version of the "Pepsi Challenge".
However,
while Pepsi and Coke have been around for over 100 years, Melissa
Hernandez, as noted, has been around for two fights: a very narrow
win over Zhang Mao Mao, in Hernandez's pro debut, and then a
17 second "pushover" of Jennifer Johnson, who came into the
bout with an 0-1 record. I really don't know whether Melissa
Hernandez is going to be a good fighter, but, on the upside, she has
the benefit of being guided by Belinda Laracuente, who is a good
fighter. If Laracuente is able to pass on some her ring skills to
Hernandez, Melissa could have a big future in the sport.
Likewise,
Maureen Shea has yet to be significantly tested in the ring, but she
also has the benefit of good guidance from boxing veterans, Luigi Olcese and Hector Roca and the "early returns" on Shea as a fighter
have been positive. If both these fighters continue to develop their
skills and move up through the featherweight ranks, when and if they
fight it could be an extremely compelling bout.
Both Hernandez and
Shea are from the Bronx and theirs is a natural rivalry, the kind
that throughout the history of the sport has provided fans with the
type of fervor that makes for bubbles in the blood. To achieve that
level of fan interest, the element that the Shea/Hernandez rivalry
now needs is further experience and skill development on the part of
both fighters What it doesn't need is any more "callouts."
Will all the problems of the sport of Women's boxing be solved if
Jelena Mrdjenovich and Jessica Rakoczy get in the ring in the near
future or if Melissa Hernandez and Maureen Shea continue their way
up the ranks of the sport and finally settle the issue of who's the
best female featherweight in the Bronx? Of course not! But it will
be a good start on eliminating one of the minor problems in the
sport, silly public challenges, known as "callouts."
I hope Rakoczy/Mrdjenovich
happens soon and I hope Shea/Hernandez happens in the future and
when those bouts do happen, it will be a result of good fighters
wanting to climb in the ring with other good fighters. It certainly
won't happen as a result of a "callout."